| Both sides previous revision Previous revision Next revision | Previous revision |
| decisions:todo2 [2025/05/26 00:00] – [Meinungen] andi | decisions:todo2 [2025/06/18 12:12] (current) – [Optionen] andi |
|---|
| == Optionen | == Optionen |
| |
| * [Taiga](https://www.taiga.io) | - [Vikunja](https://vikunja.io) |
| | * … |
| | |
| | - [Taiga](https://www.taiga.io) |
| * https://community.taiga.io/t/the-5-min-kanban-module-overview/122 | * https://community.taiga.io/t/the-5-min-kanban-module-overview/122 |
| * [Planka](https://planka.app) | |
| | - [Planka](https://planka.app) |
| * Demo: https://plankanban.github.io/planka/ | * Demo: https://plankanban.github.io/planka/ |
| * … | |
| |
| == Vergleich | - … |
| |
| ^ ^ Taiga ^ Planka ^ OpenProject ^ | |
| ^ Webseite | https://www.taiga.io | https://planka.app | https://www.openproject.org | | |
| ^ Programmiersprache | Python (Django) | JavaScript (Node.js, Vue.js) | Ruby on Rails | | |
| ^ Datenbanken | PostgreSQL | PostgreSQL | PostgreSQL, MySQL, MariaDB | | |
| ^ Lizenz | AGPLv3 | MIT | GPLv3 | | |
| ^ Quellcode | https://github.com/taigaio/taiga-back | https://github.com/plankanban/planka | https://github.com/opf/openproject | | |
| | | | | | | |
| ^ Features |||| | |
| ^ Kanban-Boards | Ja | Ja | Ja | | |
| ^ Backlogs/Epics | Ja | Nein | Ja | | |
| ^ Gantt-Charts | Nein | Nein | Ja | | |
| ^ Benutzerfreundlichkeit | Modern, etwas komplexer | Sehr schlank, minimal | Zu komplex für unseren Use-Case, viele Features | | |
| ^ Community/Verbreitung | Mittel | Klein | Groß | | |
| | | | | | | |
| ^ Schnittstellen |||| | |
| ^ Benachrichtigungen | E-Mail | E-Mail | E-Mail, In-App | | |
| ^ Matrix-Integration | Nein | Nein | Nein | | |
| ^ REST-API verfügbar | [[https://taigaio.github.io/taiga-doc/dist/api.html|Ja]][Ja](https://taigaio.github.io/taiga-doc/dist/api.html) | [[https://github.com/plankanban/planka#api|Ja]][Ja](https://github.com/plankanban/planka#api) | [[https://docs.openproject.org/api/|Ja]][Ja](https://docs.openproject.org/api/) | | |
| ^ OIDC-Unterstützung | via Community-Plugin ([taiga-contrib-oidc-auth](https://github.com/taigaio/taiga-contrib-oidc-auth), hat aber [aktuell keine aktive Entwicklung](https://community.taiga.io/t/taiga-and-oidc-plugin/4866/2)) | Ja ([nativ](https://docs.planka.cloud/docs/configuration/oidc)) | Ja, aber Enterprise-Feature | | |
| ^ Integrationen | ? | ? | Nextcloud, Github, Gitlab | | |
| |
| == Meinungen | |
| |
| ~~DISCUSSION~~ | == Vergleich |
| |
| | ^ ^ Vikunja ^ Taiga ^ Planka ^ OpenProject ^ |
| | ^ Webseite | https://vikunja.io | https://www.taiga.io | https://planka.app | https://www.openproject.org | |
| | ^ Programmiersprache | Go (Backend), \\ Vue.js (Frontend) | Python (Django) | JavaScript (Node.js, Vue.js) | Ruby on Rails | |
| | ^ Datenbanken | PostgreSQL, SQLite, MySQL/MariaDB | PostgreSQL | PostgreSQL | PostgreSQL, MySQL/MariaDB | |
| | ^ Lizenz | GPLv3 | AGPLv3 | MIT | GPLv3 | |
| | ^ Quellcode | https://github.com/go-vikunja/vikunja | https://github.com/taigaio/taiga-back | https://github.com/plankanban/planka | https://github.com/opf/openproject | |
| | | | | | | | |
| | ^ Features ^^^^ |
| | ^ Kanban-Boards | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | |
| | ^ Backlogs/Epics | Nein | Ja | Nein | Ja | |
| | ^ Gantt-Charts | Ja | Nein | Nein | Ja | |
| | ^ Benutzerfreundlichkeit | Modern, task-orientiert | Modern, etwas komplexer | Sehr schlank, minimal | Zu komplex für unseren Use-Case, viele Features | |
| | ^ Community/Verbreitung | Wächst, aktiv gepflegt | Mittel | Klein | Groß | |
| | | | | | | | |
| | ^ Schnittstellen ^^^^ |
| | ^ Benachrichtigungen | E-Mail, CalDAV | E-Mail | E-Mail | E-Mail, In-App | |
| | ^ Matrix-Integration | Nein | Nein | Nein | Nein | |
| | ^ APIs | [[https://try.vikunja.io/api/v1/docs|REST]], WebDAV, CalDAV (alpha) | [[https://taigaio.github.io/taiga-doc/dist/api.html|REST]] | [[https://github.com/plankanban/planka#api|REST]] | [[https://docs.openproject.org/api/|REST]], Webhooks | |
| | ^ OIDC | [[https://vikunja.io/docs/openid/|Ja (nativ)]] | via Community-Plugin \\ ([[https://github.com/taigaio/taiga-contrib-oidc-auth|taiga-contrib-oidc-auth]], hat aber [[https://community.taiga.io/t/taiga-and-oidc-plugin/4866/2|aktuell keine aktive Entwicklung]]) | [[https://docs.planka.cloud/docs/configuration/oidc|Ja (nativ)]] | Ja, aber Enterprise-Feature | |
| | ^ Integrationen | ? | GitHub, GitLab, Jenkins, Slack (via Webhooks) | Keine spezifisch dokumentiert, nur generische Webhooks & API | Nextcloud, GitHub, GitLab, Jira, LDAP, E-Mail (teilweise nur Enterprise) | |
| == Entscheidung | == Entscheidung |
| |
| TBD | TBD |
| | |
| | |
| | ~~DISCUSSION~~ |
| | |
| | |
| ---- struct data ---- | ---- struct data ---- |
| decision.title : Wekan-Ersatz | decision.title : Wekan-Ersatz |